What you should know when choosing non-toxic play dough on Welpr:

  • Only the cleanest products make it onto Welpr.
  • We use a score called the Welpr Rating to rank each product.
  • The Welpr Rating is based on math, not opinion, ensuring it's free from human bias.
The Welpr Rating is determined by a scoring formula. The formula takes into account the products safety, user satisfaction, and eco-ethical standing. Click here to learn more.
Our Methodology and Ratings

Find Non-Toxic Play Dough

Air Dough - Modeling Clay

Air Dough - Modeling Clay
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.65
/5
Buy Now
Buy Now
on Amazon
tooltip icon
tooltip icon

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. An EXCELLENT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the top third of the best products.
Est. Price
$12.99

Product Details

arrow down
  • Super lightweight, unscented, non-toxic, and gluten-free modeling compound
  • Stimulates creativity and play-based learning for ages 3+
  • Can help amplify critical thinking ability, confidence, and educational development
  • Offers a fun and creative alternative to electronic entertainment
  • Complies with ASTM D4236 and EN-71 standards for non-toxicity
  • Mess-free and easy to clean up, won't stick to fabric or carpet
  • Tutorial videos available on the Scentco website
  • Designed and tested in the USA to meet the highest standards
  • Dries overnight to transform creations into permanent masterpieces
  • Can be decorated with various materials like smarkers, acrylic paint, and glitter
  • Easy to mold and mix with colors or sparkles

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros Mentioned

  • Easy
  • Durable
  • Fun

Cons Mentioned

  • Smelly

Ingredients

arrow down

Ingredients can vary by product variation and may change at any time by the manufacturer. For the most complete and up-to-date list of ingredients, refer to the product packaging.


Ingredients: Clay

Colorations - Wheat & Gluten Free Classic Dough

Colorations - Wheat & Gluten Free Classic Dough
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.55
/5
Buy Now
Buy Now
on Amazon
tooltip icon
tooltip icon

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. A GREAT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the middle third of the best products.
Est. Price
$17.99

arrow down

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros Mentioned

  • Soft
  • Vibrant
  • Fun

Cons Mentioned

  • Smears

arrow down

Philodogs - Masa Playdough

Philodogs - Masa Playdough
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.55
/5
Buy Now
Buy Now
on Amazon
tooltip icon
tooltip icon

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. A GREAT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the middle third of the best products.
Est. Price
$18.99

Product Details

arrow down
  • Natural materials: Made from food-grade raw materials including wheat flour, purified water, and salt. Non-toxic playdough for kids ages 3+, gentle, healthy, and eco-friendly.
  • Updated hygienic individual packaging: Newly independent candy packaging allows children and toddlers to open more easily. Clean and convenient.
  • Rich playdough accessories tools: Comes with 4 molds that include 12 kinds of fruits and vegetables. Helps develop kids' imagination.
  • Easy-open dough recyclable sealed crisper: Each mini dough is equipped with a food-grade sealed crisper to prevent drying and hardening. Can be stored in a refrigerator for next use.
  • Easy to carry: 48 mini playdough packs and 4 tools packed in one sealed crisper. Good choice for kids' birthday gifts and arts and crafts play.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros Mentioned

  • Fun
  • Vibrant
  • Durable

Cons Mentioned

  • Messy

Ingredients

arrow down

Ingredients can vary by product variation and may change at any time by the manufacturer. For the most complete and up-to-date list of ingredients, refer to the product packaging.


Ingredients: Wheat Flour, Purified Water, Salt

Bio DoUgh - Natural Colored Dough

Bio DoUgh - Natural Colored Dough
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.45
/5
Buy Now
Buy Now
on Amazon
tooltip icon
tooltip icon

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. A GOOD user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the bottom third of the best products.
Est. Price
$32.95

Product Details

arrow down
  • All natural elements sourced from certified Australian suppliers.
  • Made in Australia.
  • Naturally preserved for kids' safety.
  • Made of organic food grade ingredients (non-toxic).
  • Available in 9 colors and scents using food grade colors and fragrance.
  • Stimulates kids' visual, tactile, and olfactory senses.
  • Very malleable and mixable dough.
  • Rehydratable with water.
  • Free from peanuts, tree nuts, soy, dairy, casein, and egg.
  • Contains wheat and salt.
  • Vegan-friendly and safe for children.
  • Encourages creativity and sensory play.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros Mentioned

  • Vibrant
  • Malleable
  • Non-toxic

Cons Mentioned

  • Sticky

arrow down

Hygloss - Play Dough

Hygloss - Play Dough
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.45
/5
Buy Now
Buy Now
on Amazon
tooltip icon
tooltip icon

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. A GOOD user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the bottom third of the best products.
Est. Price
$23.64

Product Details

arrow down
  • Unscented play dough comes in a variety of colors
  • 1 lb of modeling dough packed in a resealable container for quick clean-up and long-lasting use
  • Includes an activity guide
  • Non-toxic and made of natural food-grade ingredients
  • Contains no nuts, dairy, eggs, gelatin, latex or corn, but does contain wheat
  • Aids in fine motor skill development, improving hand and finger muscles
  • Teaches color mixing by combining primary colors to create secondary colors
  • Made in the USA
  • Suitable for ages 3 and up and conforms to ASTM-D4236

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros Mentioned

  • Soft
  • Moldable
  • Affordable

Cons Mentioned

  • Crumbly

arrow down
Our Product Rating System

Our Product Rating System

First, Camille (co-creator of Welpr) hand picks cleaner product options from a variety of sources.

Next, we collect information about each product's safety, consumer satisfaction, and eco-ethical standing.

Finally, we run all this information through an algorithm that calculates the Welpr Rating.

Welpr Rating:

5.0/5

The Welpr Rating takes into account 3 things:

  1. Product Safety
  2. Consumer Satisfaction
  3. Ethics & Environment
Product safety

Part 1: Product safety

We evaluate safety information from 3rd party organizations (e.g. EWG, Made Safe, etc.). Instead of relying solely on any one of these companies for safety information, we assess all of them.

Consumer satisfaction

Part 2: Consumer satisfaction

We scour the web for consumer ratings and reviews to verify products are not only cleaner options, but also effective. Products can either be Above Average, Average, or Below average for their respective category (e.g. cleaning products).

Ethics & Environment

Part 3: Ethics & Environment

When you buy a product, you’re supporting that company with your dollars. We believe it’s important to support ethical companies, so we pool together certifications that verify a company's ethics and environmental impact.

Chemical Name

Why it’s harmful

No items found.
about icon

About The Author

Camille May

Hey, I’m Camille, co-creator of Welpr and your clean living guide. After selling my last company in the health food space, I went non-toxic to heal an autoimmune condition. It did wonders for my health, but navigating which products to buy wasn’t easy. We created Welpr to make that journey feel a little bit easier. When I’m not working on Welpr, you can find me at the farmers market or unwinding in the sauna, always in bed at 9pm with a good book. I live in my hometown of Austin, TX with my pit bull, Romeo.