Best Non-Toxic Dog Food

Pros

• Extremely palatable; even picky eaters get excited for it, and multiple people report dogs (and cats) going crazy over the taste.
• Nib size works well as a treat, training reward, kibble topper, meal mixer, or full meal, so one bag serves multiple purposes.
• Crunchy but not as hard as kibble, which makes it manageable for smaller breeds and older dogs.
• Nibs are small enough to fit through auto-feeder chutes and work as portion-controlled training rewards without needing to break them apart.

Cons

• The bag can look significantly underfilled relative to its size, which feels misleading.
• Has a noticeable smell out of the bag that some people found strong.
• Feeding too much at once caused digestive upset in at least one case; transitioning gradually may matter more than with typical kibble.

Pros

• Picky eaters consistently go for it, including dogs that refuse most other dry foods.
• Multiple people noticed improved digestion, higher energy levels, and shinier coats after switching.
• The freeze-dried raw pieces mixed into the kibble add variety and get eaten first.
• No strong or unpleasant smell from the food itself.

Cons

• Kibble pieces are small, which can be a drawback for large dogs.
• The 3.5-pound bag feels underfilled relative to what you'd expect for the price.

Pros

• Dogs and cats eat it eagerly, including picky eaters that refuse other foods.
• Multiple people report noticeable coat improvements and better digestion in their pets after switching.
• Arrives frozen solid in insulated packaging, even when shipping takes longer than expected.
• Each tube is one pound, making it easy to portion and thaw only what you need.
• Works well for both dogs and cats across different life stages, from kittens and puppies to seniors.

Cons

• The green tripe variety has a strong smell, which is expected but worth knowing if you're handling it indoors.
• One person noted the ice packing had nearly melted on arrival, raising concerns about freshness during warmer shipping conditions.

Pros

• Most dogs took to it eagerly, even picky eaters.
• Multiple owners reported firmer stools and improved digestion after switching.
• One owner saw dramatic improvement in chronic skin issues after three bags, including hair regrowth and no more sores or redness.
• Kibble pieces are small, which works well for smaller or senior dogs that have trouble chewing larger pieces.

Cons

• The raw coating is barely noticeable; one person described it as just dust on otherwise normal kibble.
• Kibble size is very small, which may require more effort at mealtime for larger dogs.
• A few dogs refused to eat it entirely.

Pros

• Dogs consistently go for it eagerly, including picky eaters and dogs raised on raw diets.
• No prep needed; works well as a standalone meal or as a kibble topper.
• One owner saw noticeable weight gain and increased energy in an underweight dog after switching.

Cons

• Kibble breaks down into powder during shipping or handling; multiple people reported a significant portion of the bag was dust rather than intact pieces.
• The resealable zipper on the bag doesn't connect properly, making storage difficult.
• High price point is a recurring concern, especially given the amount of product lost to crumbling.

Pros

• Dogs consistently go crazy for it, even picky eaters who refuse other foods.
• Pieces are easy to crumble over kibble or feed whole, and work well as a topper to hide pills.
• Cube size (roughly half an inch) makes them practical for training treats and small dogs.
• Multiple people noticed improved digestion and firmer stools after switching.
• Rehydrates cleanly without the mess of traditional wet food.

Cons

• The rehydration instructions don't specify how much water to add, so you have to guess.
• The bag's resealable zipper broke immediately for one person.
• Pieces may be a bit large for very small dogs if fed whole.