As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate links do not affect our ratings. Learn more.

Best Non-Toxic Eyebrow Pencils

We vetted eyebrow pencils against the Welpr Standard and here are our top picks.

Camille May

Cofounder & Product Curator

Olushola M. Awoyemi

Medical Reviewer, PhD

Here's what we look for:

Simple formulas made with ingredients that meet our standard
Free from parabens, PEGs, phthalates, sulfates, BHA/BHT, formaldehyde and formaldehyde-releasing ingredients, and undisclosed fragrance
Mineral pigments or alternatives tested for heavy metals
EU-compliant brands and third-party certifications when available
Transparent sourcing, ingredients, and manufacturing practices

Best Non-Toxic Eyebrow Pencils

On Welpr, terms like "non-toxic," "safer," "cleaner," "healthier," and "vetted" are editorial labels based on our own standard for product assessment. They are not guarantees, certifications, or medical claims. Learn more.

Meets the Welpr Standard

Top Pick

RMS Beauty

Back2Brow Pencil

Free From: Cruelty Free
Highlights: Vegan, Cruelty-free, Fragrance-free, Recycled materials, Traditional wood, Natural finish

8.6

Performance score

Where to buy

Amazon
See price
Credo Beauty
See price

Pros

Glides on smoothly without requiring much pressure, which is especially helpful for filling in sparse or thinning brows.
Pigmentation is easy to control, making it simple to build from a subtle to a more defined look.
Colors read natural and don't pull red, so filled-in brows don't look obviously drawn on.
Comes with a built-in spoolie that blends product well and an included sharpener.

Cons

The soft formula means it needs sharpening frequently, which wastes product.
Staying power is limited; the creamy texture can slide off with sweat or oil.
Only three shades are available, so finding an exact match can be tricky.

Classic wooden brow pencil with a creamy, buildable formula that fills in sparse areas and adds definition without looking drawn on. One end is the pencil; the other is a spoolie for blending out strokes into a more diffused, natural finish.
The formula includes botanical oils intended to nourish brow hairs over time, not just color them. It's more of a skincare-meets-makeup approach than a purely cosmetic pencil.
Comes in three shades (Light, Medium, Dark) matched to hair color rather than skin tone. Light, for example, is a beige taupe designed for blonde to light brown hair.
RMS Beauty ships a sharpener with the pencil, which matters because wooden pencils need regular sharpening to stay precise. There's also a protective wax layer on the tip that needs to be sharpened off before first use.
Among non-toxic eyebrow pencils, the format here is deliberately old-school: a sharpenable wooden pencil rather than a twist-up or mechanical tip. That gives you more control over point shape but requires a bit more maintenance.
Founded in 2009 by makeup artist Rose-Marie Swift, RMS was built around the idea that professional-grade cosmetics could be made with food-grade and organic ingredients. The packaging is recyclable aluminum and wood, with the outer carton made from 80% post-consumer recycled paper.

Simmondsia Chinensis (Jojoba) Seed Oil
Beeswax/Cera Alba/Cire D'Abeille
Bis-Diglyceryl Polyacyladipate-2
Mica
Copernicia Cerifera (Carnauba) Wax/Cera Carnauba/Cire De Carnauba
Silica
Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride
Squalane
Helianthus Annuus (Sunflower) Seed Oil
Tocopherol
Rosmarinus Officinalis (Rosemary) Leaf Extract
Beta-Sitosterol
Squalene
Polyglyceryl-3 Diisostearate
Carthamus Tinctorius (Safflower) Flower Extract
Hibiscus Sabdariffa Flower Extract
Iron Oxides (Ci 77491, Ci 77492, Ci 77499)
Titanium Dioxide (Ci 77891)

Free email mini-course

Welpr Blueprint: Go Non-Toxic Mini-Course

The 80/20 guide to going non-toxic the easy way.

Meets the Welpr Standard

Budget Pick

Araza Beauty

Avocado Butter Brow Pencil

Free From: Gluten Free
Highlights: Cruelty-free, Made in USA, No synthetic fragrance, Traditional wood, Natural finish

8.2

Performance score

Where to buy

Araza Beauty
See price

Sharpen-style brow pencil (not a twist-up) with a creamy, butter-based formula built from botanical oils and waxes rather than petroleum or synthetic film-formers. The texture is soft and glides on without pulling, so it's geared toward a natural, filled-in look rather than crisp, sculpted lines.
Pigment is buildable and blends out easily, giving a softer finish than most long-wear brow products. The trade-off is that it's not waterproof and may need light touch-ups during the day.
Available in six shades from platinum blonde to black. If you're unsure about your match, Araza offers shade-matching by email using a bare-face selfie in natural light.
The formula is vegan and entirely plant-based, which is uncommon among non-toxic eyebrow pencils; many in this category still rely on beeswax or synthetic binders for structure.
Because it's wax-and-butter-based with no synthetic stabilizers, the pencil's firmness can shift with temperature. Storing it in a cool, dry spot helps keep the consistency predictable.

Meets the Welpr Standard

Kosas

Brow Pop Defining Pencil

Free From: Cruelty Free, Fragrance Free
Certified: Leaping Bunny
Highlights: Vegan, Cruelty-free, Fragrance-free, Natural finish, Waterproof

8.4

Performance score

Where to buy

Amazon
See price
Credo Beauty
See price

Video Review

Watch

Pros

Stays put through a full day, including sweat, without fading or needing touch-ups.
The shade range works well across hair colors, including hard-to-match tones like light blonde and natural red.
Buildable formula that only needs a light touch to get good coverage.
The built-in brush on the opposite end makes application and blending easy.

Cons

The formula is very soft and snaps easily if you press too hard.
The pencil tip is thicker than some people want for precise, hair-like strokes.
The pencil can slide out of the holder if the cap isn't kept on the pencil end.

The pencil tip is a micro triangle shape, not a standard round or chisel tip. The thinner point draws hair-like strokes for definition, while the wider flat side fills in sparse areas more quickly.
Comes with a built-in spoolie on the opposite end, so you can brush through and soften strokes without needing a separate tool.
The formula has a creamy texture that glides without tugging on skin or pulling out brow hairs, but it's firm enough to hold the triangular tip's shape for precise application.
Works on its own for a natural look or as a base layer under brow gels. If you have laminated or microbladed brows, it's compatible with those treatments too.
Kosas formulates for sensitive skin and runs clinical safety testing on all products, which is relevant context if you're comparing non-toxic eyebrow pencils and have reactive skin.
Available in ten shades spanning blonde to black, including a grey option, which is less common in the category.

Meets the Welpr Standard

Ere Perez

Natural Almond Eyebrow Pencil

Free From: Cruelty Free, Non-GMO
Certified: CarbonNeutral, PETA Certified
Highlights: Vegan, Cruelty-free, No synthetic fragrance, Traditional wood, Waterproof

8.4

Performance score

Where to buy

Amazon
See price
Ere Perez
See price

Pros

Applies smoothly and gives a natural, not drawn-on look, especially with a light tapping technique.
Color lasts all day without needing touch-ups.
The tip is sturdy and doesn't snap or break like some competing pencils.
Built-in brush on the cap is a useful addition for blending.
Easy to control even for people who aren't confident with brow makeup.

Cons

The tip is on the thicker side, so people who prefer a fine, precise line may find it limiting.
Shade reads differently in person than expected; the middle shade leans taupe or mauve rather than a true neutral brown, which doesn't work for everyone.

Traditional wooden pencil format with a built-in spoolie on the opposite end for blending color and grooming hairs into place.
The formula uses plant-based oils and waxes to condition brow hairs and nourish the skin underneath as you fill, so it's doing double duty rather than just depositing pigment.
Creamy texture that's meant to fill sparse areas with soft, buildable coverage rather than sharp, drawn-on lines. It's geared toward a natural, feathered look.
Formulated for sensitive skin, which matters more around the brows than people realize since that skin is thinner and closer to the eyes. One of the more straightforward options among non-toxic eyebrow pencils.
Ere Perez launched in 2002 out of Bondi Beach, Sydney, founded by a Mexican-born naturopath. The brand started with a single natural mascara and built out from there, so brow and lash products are core to what they do.

Meets the Welpr Standard

Westman Atelier

Bonne Brow Defining Pencil

Free From: Cruelty Free, Formaldehyde Free, Paraben Free, Phthalate Free, Sulfate Free
Highlights: Vegan, Cruelty-free, Fragrance-free, Retractable

8.3

Performance score

Where to buy

Credo Beauty
See price
Sephora
See price

Video Review

Watch

Dual-ended brow pencil with a firm tip on one side for hair-like strokes and a detachable dry spoolie on the other for blending and grooming.
The formula is buildable, so you can layer from a soft, natural fill to a bolder, fuller brow depending on the day.
Pigments are 100% naturally derived, which is worth noting if you're comparing non-toxic eyebrow pencils and care about how color is sourced.
Four shades mapped to hair color: cool blonde, taupey blonde, woodsy brown, and subtle black. The brand's guidance is to pick about two shades deeper than your hair.
Westman Atelier is founded by makeup artist Gucci Westman, and the line is built around a clean formulation approach with products sold through retailers like Credo that vet ingredient standards.

Meets the Welpr Standard

Inika

Organic Brow Pencil

Free From: Cruelty Free
Certified: Certified Plastic Neutral, PETA Certified
Highlights: Vegan, Cruelty-free, Traditional wood, Waterproof

8.3

Performance score

Where to buy

Amazon
See price

Traditional sharpen-to-use wood pencil with a built-in spoolie on the opposite end for blending and grooming after application.
The formula uses plant-based waxes and oils to glide on without tugging or dragging, and it leaves a water-resistant finish rather than a waxy residue.
Comes in three shades (Blonde, Brunette, Dark Brunette), all with fairly neutral undertones. Worth noting that the Dark Brunette can lean slightly warm/red depending on your natural coloring.
Housed in wood and aluminum rather than plastic, which is consistent with INIKA's broader push as a plastic-neutral makeup brand. Among non-toxic eyebrow pencils, that packaging approach is uncommon.
Formulated for sensitive skin. The emollient-heavy base conditions the brow area while you wear it, so it doubles as light skin care rather than just sitting on top as pure pigment.

Meets the Welpr Standard

Toups & Co

Brow Pencil

Free From: Gluten Free, Non-GMO, Paraben Free, PFAS Free, Phthalate Free, Sulfate Free
Highlights: Vegan, Breastfeeding safe, Recyclable packaging, Money-back guarantee, Twist-up, Natural finish

8.2

Performance score

Where to buy

Toups & Co
See price

A twist-up brow pencil with a slanted tip on one end and a built-in spoolie brush on the other, so you can fill, shape, and blend without switching tools.
The formula is wax-based and goes on creamy, laying down color in buildable, hair-like strokes rather than waxy drag. Designed to add fullness to sparse areas without looking drawn on.
Three shades map to hair color: Soft Taupe for light blondes, greys, and very light browns; Deep Taupe for medium browns; Deep Brown for dark browns.
Among non-toxic eyebrow pencils, this one keeps the ingredient list unusually short, relying on plant-derived waxes and oils rather than synthetic binders or film formers.
Handcrafted in small batches in coastal Alabama by a family-run operation that started on a regenerative farm. Shelf life is about a year once opened, since there are no synthetic preservatives extending it.

Meets the Welpr Standard

Omiana

Mineral Brow Pencils

Free From: Cruelty Free, Formaldehyde Free, Fragrance Free, Gluten Free, Non-GMO, Paraben Free, Phthalate Free, Sulfate Free
Certified: Leaping Bunny, PETA Certified
Highlights: Built-in spoolie, For sensitive skin, All brow types, Moisturizing ingredients, Boron nitride-free, Talc-free, Silicone-free, Nanoparticle-free

8.2

Performance score

Where to buy

Omiana
See price

A 2-in-1 brow pencil pairs color with a built-in spoolie for filling and shaping, then brushing the product through to blend it.
The attached spiral-bristled brush combs and shapes brows, leaving them smooth and natural while helping eliminate flaking.
Moisturizing and conditioning ingredients make the formula suited to sensitive skin as well as different brow types.
Four natural-looking shade options cover light brown-blonde, warm medium brown, cool neutral dark brown, and deep grey-brown tones.

How to Swap to Non-Toxic eyebrow pencils:

Here's how to swap to non-toxic eyebrow pencils:

What to know about eyebrow pencils

Eyebrow pencils sit directly on your skin near your eyes, and most people use them daily. That combination of frequent use, direct skin contact, and close proximity to a sensitive area makes the formula worth paying attention to.

Welpr focuses on the pigments, waxes, preservatives, and any added fragrance in eyebrow pencils since these sit on your skin for hours.
Products applied near the eyes deserve extra attention because the skin there is thinner and more absorbent.

Review the eyebrow pencils you already use

Check your current eyebrow pencil to see what's actually in it. Use the Welpr Personal Care and Cosmetic Scanner to take a picture of the ingredient label and find out if anything is flagged.

Look for "fragrance" or "parfum" on the label—these are common in makeup and can indicate undisclosed synthetic ingredients.
If you use more than one brow product (pencil, gel, pomade), scan the one you reach for most often first.

Use your current eyebrow pencil more carefully

If you're not ready to replace your eyebrow pencil right away, a few small habits can help. Reducing how much product you apply and keeping it away from the inner eye area are easy adjustments.

Use light, precise strokes so less product sits on your skin throughout the day.
Sharpen traditional pencils before each use to remove the exposed, oxidized outer layer.

Choose a cleaner eyebrow pencil

Look for eyebrow pencils with simple formulas built around natural waxes, plant-based oils, and mineral pigments. The best options skip synthetic fragrance, parabens, and unnecessary preservatives entirely.

Prioritize products that are fragrance-free and use natural mineral pigments, ideally tested for heavy metals—certifications like EWG VERIFIED™ or MADE SAFE® are a good sign.
Click the button above to shop Welpr Approved eyebrow pencils.

Camille May

Cofounder & Product Curator

Camille May is the co-creator of Welpr and a guide for clean living. After selling her last company in the health food space, she went non-toxic while working to heal an autoimmune condition....

View full profile

Olushola M. Awoyemi

Medical Reviewer, PhD

Olushola M. Awoyemi (aka Shola) is a board-certified toxicologist and a research scientist with a PhD in Environmental Toxicology. Shola's long-term ambition is to be recognized as a world-renowned expert in toxicology,...

View full profile