Zuzu Luxe
Eye Defining Pencil
Est. Price$15.20
10.0
Performance
Ingredient Safety
Meets the Welpr Standard
Buy Now
on Amazon
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Vegan
Cruelty-free
Made in EU
Hypoallergenic
Pencil
Waterproof
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate links do not affect our ratings. Learn more.
Best Non-Toxic Eyeliners
We vetted eyeliners against the Welpr Standard and here are our top picks.
Cofounder & Product Curator
Medical Reviewer, PhD
Here's what we look for:
- Simple formulas with minimal, non-irritating preservatives
- No parabens, PEGs, phthalates, sulfates, BHA/BHT, formaldehyde or formaldehyde-releasing ingredients, or undisclosed synthetic fragrance (unless certified safe)
- Mineral pigments or safe alternatives tested for heavy metals
- EU-compliant brands and third-party certifications when available
- Transparent sourcing, ingredients, and manufacturing practices
Best Non-Toxic Eyeliners
On Welpr, terms like "non-toxic," "safer," "cleaner," "healthier," and "vetted" are editorial labels based on our own standard for product assessment. They are not guarantees, certifications, or medical claims. Learn more.
Free email mini-course
Welpr Blueprint: Go Non-Toxic Mini-Course
The 80/20 guide to going non-toxic the easy way.
Gabriel Cosmetics
Classic Eyeliner
Est. Price$13.20
8.7
Performance
Ingredient Safety
Meets the Welpr Standard
Buy Now
on Amazon
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Vegan
Cruelty-free
Made in USA
Pencil
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Vegan
Cruelty-free
Plastic-free packaging
Pencil
Product image coming soon
RMS Beauty
Straight Line Eye Pencil
Est. Price$25
9.2
Performance
Ingredient Safety
Meets the Welpr Standard
Buy Now
on Credo Beauty
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Vegan
Cruelty-free
Fragrance-free
Recycled materials
Kohl
Zuzu Luxe
Liquid Eyeliner
Est. Price$17.15
9.0
Performance
Ingredient Safety
Meets the Welpr Standard
Buy Now
on Amazon
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Vegan
Cruelty-free
Made in USA
Hypoallergenic
Fragrance-free
Recyclable packaging
Liquid
Waterproof
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Vegan
Cruelty-free
Fragrance-free
Kohl
Well People
Fresh Lines Liquid Eyeliner
Est. Price$18
8.3
Performance
Ingredient Safety
Meets the Welpr Standard
Buy Now
on Amazon
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Vegan
Cruelty-free
Fragrance-free
No synthetic fragrance
Liquid
Fitglow Beauty
Natural Vegan Eyeliner Pencil
Est. Price$24
8.0
Performance
Ingredient Safety
Meets the Welpr Standard
Buy Now
on Amazon
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Vegan
Cruelty-free
Pencil
Inika
Organic Eye Pencil
Est. Price$25
7.3
Performance
Ingredient Safety
Meets the Welpr Standard
Buy Now
on Amazon
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Vegan
Cruelty-free
Hypoallergenic
Recyclable packaging
Recycled materials
Pencil
Toups & Co
Natural Eyeliner
Est. Price$28
7.0
Performance
Ingredient Safety
Meets the Welpr Standard
Discount Code
Use link for discountBuy Now
on Toups & Co
Certifications
Free From
Highlights
Breastfeeding safe
Recyclable packaging
Money-back guarantee
Gel
How to Swap to Non-Toxic eyeliners:
Here's how to swap to non-toxic eyeliners:
What to know about eyeliner
Eyeliner is applied directly to one of the most sensitive and absorbent areas of your body — the skin around your eyes. Because most people use it daily and it sits on the skin for hours, the formulation and pigments matter more than in many other product categories.
- Welpr focuses on what eyeliner is made of: the pigments, preservatives, fragrances, and base ingredients that make up the formula.
- Products used near the eyes deserve extra attention because the skin there is thinner and more permeable than most other areas.
Check your current eyeliner
Take a look at the eyeliners you use most often and scan them with the Welpr Personal Care and Cosmetic Scanner. The scanner reads ingredient labels and flags anything that may not meet Welpr's standards.
- Start with the eyeliner you reach for every day — that's the one with the most cumulative contact with your skin.
- If you use multiple types (pencil, liquid, gel), prioritize liquid or gel formulas first since they tend to contain more preservatives and additives.
Use your current eyeliner more carefully
If you're not ready to replace your eyeliner right away, a few small habits can help reduce unnecessary exposure while you transition.
- Apply eyeliner to the outer lash line rather than the inner waterline, which is closer to the eye's surface and more absorbent.
- Remove eyeliner thoroughly at the end of the day so it doesn't sit on your skin overnight.
Choose a cleaner eyeliner
Look for eyeliners with simple formulas built around natural mineral pigments and without harsh preservatives. Certifications like EWG VERIFIED™ are good signals, but Welpr reviews every formula individually beyond just certifications.
- Avoid eyeliners that list "fragrance" or "parfum" on the label, and look for brands that confirm their pigments are tested for heavy metals.
- Click the button above to shop Welpr Approved eyeliner.
Camille May
Cofounder & Product Curator
Camille May is the co-creator of Welpr and a guide for clean living. After selling her last company in the health food space, she went non-toxic while working to heal an autoimmune condition....
Olushola M. Awoyemi
Medical Reviewer, PhD
Olushola M. Awoyemi (aka Shola) is a board-certified toxicologist and a research scientist with a PhD in Environmental Toxicology. Shola's long-term ambition is to be recognized as a world-renowned expert in toxicology,...