The Welpr Rating is determined by a scoring formula. The formula takes into account the products safety, user satisfaction, and eco-ethical standing. Click here to learn more.

What we look for:

  • Materials like stainless steel, cast iron, ceramic, and glass (never plastic)
  • 100% PFAS-free nonstick coatings, with ceramic tested for heavy metals
  • Aluminum only if it’s hard anodized, ceramic-coated, or safely encased in stainless
  • Full material transparency from brands we trust

View our full standards here.

Our Methodology and Ratings

Find Non-Toxic Loaf Pan

Anchor Hocking - Loaf Pan (1.5 Qt)

Anchor Hocking - Loaf Pan (1.5 Qt)
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.9
/5
tooltip icon

Highlights

tooltip icon
This product is free from heavy metals like lead and cadmium, which can build up in the body and are linked to developmental, reproductive, and organ toxicity.
This product does not contain PTFE (aka Teflon), a nonstick coating and one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to hormone and immune disruption.
The Made in USA label indicates that a product has substantial U.S. content and manufacturing.
This product does not contain PFAS, a group of forever chemicals used to make things nonstick, stain-resistant, or waterproof. That includes PTFE, PFOA, and thousands of other compounds linked to hormone disruption and long-term health risks.
This product is dishwasher safe.
This product does not contain PFOA, one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to liver damage and immune issues.
<p>This product is <a href="https://www.welpr.com/certifications#welpr-approved" target="_blank">Welpr Approved</a>, meaning it has been vetted against our <a href="https://www.welpr.com/how-we-vet-products/kitchen" target="_blank">kitchen standards</a> and contains no harmful materials or coatings from our no list.</p>
<p><a href="https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65" target="_blank">California Prop 65</a> requires businesses to provide a warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. This product does NOT contain any chemicals that require a warning. <a href="https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/65789c6c167b3634c7214ad6/664613faf88803657a5b8d5c_anchor%20hocking.png" target="_blank">Source</a>.</p>

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. An EXCELLENT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the top third of the best products.

Materials

tooltip icon

Glass

Est. Price
$15.68
price-icon-1price-icon-2price-icon-3

Product Details

arrow down
  • Tempered glass construction is safe for use in microwave, oven, refrigerator, and freezer.
  • BPA-free lids ensure there are no harmful chemicals leaching into your food.
  • Does not warp, stain, retain smells, or leach dangerous chemicals.
  • Made in the USA, ensuring high quality and safety standards.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros

  • Non-toxic option for health-conscious baking.
  • Durable and withstands regular use over time.
  • Even heat distribution results in uniform baking.
  • Cleans easily in the dishwasher, saving time and effort.
  • Clear glass allows for easy monitoring of baking progress.

Cons

  • Some reports of glass shattering at high oven temperatures, a concern for those baking above 350°F.

arrow down

Pyrex - Glass Loaf Dish with Lid (1.5 Qt)

Pyrex - Glass Loaf Dish with Lid (1.5 Qt)
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.9
/5
tooltip icon

Highlights

tooltip icon
This product does not contain PTFE (aka Teflon), a nonstick coating and one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to hormone and immune disruption.
The Made in USA label indicates that a product has substantial U.S. content and manufacturing.
This product does not contain PFAS, a group of forever chemicals used to make things nonstick, stain-resistant, or waterproof. That includes PTFE, PFOA, and thousands of other compounds linked to hormone disruption and long-term health risks.
This product is dishwasher safe.
This product does not contain PFOA, one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to liver damage and immune issues.
<p>This product is <a href="https://www.welpr.com/certifications#welpr-approved" target="_blank">Welpr Approved</a>, meaning it has been vetted against our <a href="https://www.welpr.com/how-we-vet-products/kitchen" target="_blank">kitchen standards</a> and contains no harmful materials or coatings from our no list.</p>
<p><a href="https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65" target="_blank">California Prop 65</a> requires businesses to provide a warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. This product does NOT contain any chemicals that require a warning. <a href="https://corelle.com/pages/ab1200" target="_blank">Source</a>.</p>

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. An EXCELLENT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the top third of the best products.

Materials

tooltip icon

Glass (Body), Plastic (Lid)

Est. Price
$14.02
price-icon-1price-icon-2price-icon-3

Product Details

arrow down
  • Tempered glass ensures durability and safety while handling hot food.
  • Wide handles provide a secure grip, preventing slips and spills.
  • Non-porous glass resists stains, flavors, and odors, ideal for food storage.
  • BPA-free lid is safe for use in the freezer, microwave, and dishwasher.
  • Designed for everyday use, safe for dishwasher, freezer, microwave, and oven.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros

  • Versatile and perfect for various cooking and baking needs.
  • Comes with snug-fitting lids, great for transitioning from oven to fridge.
  • Durable, thick glass that can handle temperature changes without worry.
  • Easy to clean, with a non-stick surface for hassle-free maintenance.
  • Space-saving design with stackable feature for small kitchens.

Cons

  • Some users might find the lid material a bit stiff, raising concerns about long-term durability.
  • Handles may take up extra oven space, which could be a consideration for those with smaller ovens.

arrow down

Xtrema - Loaf Pan (2 Qt)

Xtrema - Loaf Pan (2 Qt)
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.9
/5
tooltip icon

Highlights

tooltip icon
This product is free from heavy metals like lead and cadmium, which can build up in the body and are linked to developmental, reproductive, and organ toxicity.
California proposition 65 requires businesses to provide warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. A compliant product means it does not have this warning.
This product does not contain PTFE (aka Teflon), a nonstick coating and one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to hormone and immune disruption.
This product is induction compatible.
This product does not contain PFAS, a group of forever chemicals used to make things nonstick, stain-resistant, or waterproof. That includes PTFE, PFOA, and thousands of other compounds linked to hormone disruption and long-term health risks.
This product is dishwasher safe.
This product does not contain PFOA, one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to liver damage and immune issues.
<p>This product is <a href="https://www.welpr.com/certifications#welpr-approved" target="_blank">Welpr Approved</a>, meaning it has been vetted against our <a href="https://www.welpr.com/how-we-vet-products/kitchen" target="_blank">kitchen standards</a> and contains no harmful materials or coatings from our no list.</p>
<p><a href="https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65" target="_blank">California Prop 65</a> requires businesses to provide a warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. This product does NOT contain any chemicals that require a warning. <a href="https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/65789c6c167b3634c7214ad6/6646142364334791687c19fa_Xtrema.png" target="_blank">Source</a>.</p>
tooltip icon

Materials

tooltip icon

100% Pure Ceramic (Clay, Water, Natural Minerals and Oxides)

Est. Price
$75.00
price-icon-1price-icon-2price-icon-3

Product Details

arrow down
  • Handcrafted from 100% pure ceramic for safe, non-toxic cooking and baking.
  • Versatile loaf pan ideal for bread, meatloaf, and more, perfect from oven to table.
  • Provides even heating and excellent thermal retention for consistent results.
  • Durable, chip-resistant, scratch-proof, and stain-proof for long-lasting use.
  • Safe for microwave, oven, BBQ, freezer, and dishwasher for easy care.
  • Triple-fired at 2,500 degrees without synthetic additives or coatings.
  • Tested PFOA and PTFE free, with no extractable lead or cadmium; California Prop 65 compliant.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros

  • Perfect for those with metal sensitivities due to its non-toxic ceramic material.
  • Produces a desirable crust on bread while preventing sticking with minimal oil.
  • Durable and reliable for frequent baking needs.
  • Provides peace of mind by eliminating chemical exposure in everyday cooking and baking.

arrow down

Staub - Cake & Bread Pan (9" x 4.5")

Staub - Cake & Bread Pan (9" x 4.5")
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.9
/5
tooltip icon

Highlights

tooltip icon
This product does not contain PTFE (aka Teflon), a nonstick coating and one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to hormone and immune disruption.
This product is induction compatible.
This product is free from lead, a toxic heavy metal linked to brain development issues, reproductive harm, and long-term organ damage.
This product is free from cadmium, a heavy metal linked to kidney damage and cancer.
This product does not contain PFAS, a group of forever chemicals used to make things nonstick, stain-resistant, or waterproof. That includes PTFE, PFOA, and thousands of other compounds linked to hormone disruption and long-term health risks.
This product is dishwasher safe.
This product does not contain PFOA, one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to liver damage and immune issues.
<p>This product is <a href="https://www.welpr.com/certifications#welpr-approved" target="_blank">Welpr Approved</a>, meaning it has been vetted against our <a href="https://www.welpr.com/how-we-vet-products/kitchen" target="_blank">kitchen standards</a> and contains no harmful materials or coatings from our no list.</p>
<p><a href="https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65" target="_blank">California Prop 65</a> requires businesses to provide a warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. This product does NOT contain any chemicals that require a warning. <a href="https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/65789c6c167b3634c7214ad6/66461412d23748b96104399d_Staub.png" target="_blank">Source</a>.</p>

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. A GREAT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the middle third of the best products.

Materials

tooltip icon

Enameled Cast Iron

Est. Price
$106.84
price-icon-1price-icon-2price-icon-3

Product Details

arrow down
  • Made from durable cast iron with enamel processing for safe, non-toxic cooking.
  • Versatile and multipurpose use, ideal for baking cakes, bread, terrine, and more.
  • Induction compatible, providing easy use with modern cooktops.
  • Excellent for healthy cooking, allowing you to bake without additives or preservatives.
  • Acts as a stylish serving piece straight from the oven to the table.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros

  • High-quality craftsmanship with a brilliant finish.
  • Perfect for baking a variety of delicious recipes.
  • Effortless cleaning with simple warm water soak.
  • Versatile use for both bread and casserole dishes.

Cons

  • Some users might find it heavy due to cast iron material.

arrow down

Caraway - Nonstick Ceramic Loaf Pan (1 lb)

Caraway - Nonstick Ceramic Loaf Pan (1 lb)
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.8
/5
tooltip icon

Highlights

tooltip icon
This product is free from heavy metals like lead and cadmium, which can build up in the body and are linked to developmental, reproductive, and organ toxicity.
This product does not contain PTFE (aka Teflon), a nonstick coating and one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to hormone and immune disruption.
This product is nonstick.
This product does not contain PFAS, a group of forever chemicals used to make things nonstick, stain-resistant, or waterproof. That includes PTFE, PFOA, and thousands of other compounds linked to hormone disruption and long-term health risks.
This product does not contain PFOA, one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to liver damage and immune issues.
<p>This product is <a href="https://www.welpr.com/certifications#welpr-approved" target="_blank">Welpr Approved</a>, meaning it has been vetted against our <a href="https://www.welpr.com/how-we-vet-products/kitchen" target="_blank">kitchen standards</a> and contains no harmful materials or coatings from our no list.</p>
<p><a href="https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65" target="_blank">California Prop 65</a> requires businesses to provide a warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. This product has a warning. Click the source to review what part of the product the warning pertains to (chemicals may not come in contact with food). <a href="https://assets.ctfassets.net/dfp1t53x5luq/4ptsJVrrlaKaA3FS61G5va/6924d2c261480591d631cfb98be056fd/AB1200_Compliance_-_Updated_9_18_23.pdf" target="_blank">Source</a>.</p>

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. An EXCELLENT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the top third of the best products.

Materials

tooltip icon

Aluminum (Core), Ceramic Nonstick (Coating)

Est. Price
$45.00
price-icon-1price-icon-2price-icon-3

Product Details

arrow down
  • Naturally non-stick for an effortless baking experience and easy cleaning.
  • Non-toxic coating, free from harmful chemicals, ensuring safe baking for you and your family.
  • Perfect for baking pound cakes, banana bread, and more, enhancing any baker's repertoire.
  • Withstands oven temperatures up to 550ºF for versatile baking options.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros

  • Non-toxic ceramic coating ensures safe, healthy baking.
  • Nonstick performance allows easy bread release without greasing.
  • Even cooking results in perfectly baked loaves.
  • Lightweight design with attractive color options.
  • Effortless cleaning with just warm, soapy water.

Cons

  • Some users noticed scratching on the pan's bottom, which may concern those placing importance on aesthetics.
  • Slightly smaller size, which could matter to those who bake larger loaves.

arrow down

Lodge - Cast Iron Loaf Pan (Available in Multiple Sizes)

Lodge - Cast Iron Loaf Pan (Available in Multiple Sizes)
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.8
/5
tooltip icon

Highlights

tooltip icon
This product does not contain PTFE (aka Teflon), a nonstick coating and one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to hormone and immune disruption.
The Made in USA label indicates that a product has substantial U.S. content and manufacturing.
This product is induction compatible.
This product does not contain PFAS, a group of forever chemicals used to make things nonstick, stain-resistant, or waterproof. That includes PTFE, PFOA, and thousands of other compounds linked to hormone disruption and long-term health risks.
This product does not contain PFOA, one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to liver damage and immune issues.
<p>This product is <a href="https://www.welpr.com/certifications#welpr-approved" target="_blank">Welpr Approved</a>, meaning it has been vetted against our <a href="https://www.welpr.com/how-we-vet-products/kitchen" target="_blank">kitchen standards</a> and contains no harmful materials or coatings from our no list.</p>
<p><a href="https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65" target="_blank">California Prop 65</a> requires businesses to provide a warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. This product has a warning. Click the source to review what part of the product the warning pertains to (chemicals may not come in contact with food). <a href="https://www.lodgecastiron.com/california-ab-1200-disclosure" target="_blank">Source</a>.</p>

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. An EXCELLENT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the top third of the best products.

Materials

tooltip icon

Cast Iron

Est. Price
$19.90
price-icon-1price-icon-2price-icon-3

Product Details

arrow down
  • Naturally seasoned with 100% natural vegetable oil for a chemical-free, easy-release finish.
  • Excellent heat retention and even cooking ensure perfect baking results every time.
  • Durable cast iron construction that does not warp, dent, or bend, perfect for everyday use.
  • Made in the USA with non-toxic materials, ensuring a safe cooking experience.
  • Perfect for baking homemade creations without resorting to bakery or restaurant alternatives.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros

  • Delivers even heat distribution for perfectly baked loaves.
  • Sturdy and durable design promises a long-lasting kitchen companion.
  • Free from toxic materials, offering a safer baking option.
  • Easy to clean due to its non-stick performance when seasoned properly.
  • Perfect for a variety of breads, including sourdough and gluten-free.

Cons

  • May require specific care in washing and oiling to prevent rust for new users.
  • Some users find it a bit smaller, which might not fit larger recipes comfortably.

arrow down

Emile Henry - Bread Loaf Baker (11" x 5" x 5")

Emile Henry - Bread Loaf Baker (11" x 5" x 5")
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.8
/5
tooltip icon

Highlights

tooltip icon
This product is free from nickel, a heavy metal and common allergen known to trigger skin irritation.
California proposition 65 requires businesses to provide warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. A compliant product means it does not have this warning.
This product does not contain PTFE (aka Teflon), a nonstick coating and one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to hormone and immune disruption.
This product is free from lead, a toxic heavy metal linked to brain development issues, reproductive harm, and long-term organ damage.
This product is nonstick.
This product is free from cadmium, a heavy metal linked to kidney damage and cancer.
This product does not contain PFAS, a group of forever chemicals used to make things nonstick, stain-resistant, or waterproof. That includes PTFE, PFOA, and thousands of other compounds linked to hormone disruption and long-term health risks.
This product is dishwasher safe.
This product does not contain PFOA, one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to liver damage and immune issues.
<p>This product is <a href="https://www.welpr.com/certifications#welpr-approved" target="_blank">Welpr Approved</a>, meaning it has been vetted against our <a href="https://www.welpr.com/how-we-vet-products/kitchen" target="_blank">kitchen standards</a> and contains no harmful materials or coatings from our no list.</p>
<p><a href="https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65" target="_blank">California Prop 65</a> requires businesses to provide a warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. We have reached out to this brand to confirm their prop 65 status, but have not received a reply back.</p>

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. A GREAT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the middle third of the best products.

Materials

tooltip icon

Ceramic

Est. Price
$158.35
price-icon-1price-icon-2price-icon-3

Product Details

arrow down
  • Made from all-natural materials for health-conscious cooking.
  • Resistant to temperature changes, ensuring safe use from freezer to oven.
  • Durable and scratch-resistant glaze for everyday use and easy maintenance.
  • Dishwasher safe, simplifying cleanup after baking.
  • High resistance ceramic ensures even heat distribution for perfect baking results.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros

  • Perfect size for a variety of loaf recipes, including no-knead and sourdough.
  • Non-toxic and safe for health-conscious bakers, with no aluminum or non-stick coatings.
  • Bakes bread to perfection with an incredible crisp outer layer.
  • Easy release of the bread and simple cleanup when used correctly.

Cons

  • Some users found it tricky to prevent sticking, requiring careful preparation.
  • Lack of clear instructions may require some experimentation for best results.

arrow down

E-far - Loaf Pan for Baking Bread (9.5", Set of 3)

E-far - Loaf Pan for Baking Bread (9.5", Set of 3)
Welpr Rating
tooltip icon
Welpr rating icon
4.75
/5
tooltip icon

Highlights

tooltip icon
This product does not contain PTFE (aka Teflon), a nonstick coating and one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to hormone and immune disruption.
This product does not contain PFAS, a group of forever chemicals used to make things nonstick, stain-resistant, or waterproof. That includes PTFE, PFOA, and thousands of other compounds linked to hormone disruption and long-term health risks.
This product is dishwasher safe.
This product does not contain PFOA, one of thousands of toxic PFAS forever chemicals linked to liver damage and immune issues.
<p>This product is <a href="https://www.welpr.com/certifications#welpr-approved" target="_blank">Welpr Approved</a>, meaning it has been vetted against our <a href="https://www.welpr.com/how-we-vet-products/kitchen" target="_blank">kitchen standards</a> and contains no harmful materials or coatings from our no list.</p>
<p><a href="https://oehha.ca.gov/proposition-65" target="_blank">California Prop 65</a> requires businesses to provide a warning about exposures to certain potentially harmful chemicals. We have reached out to this brand to confirm their prop 65 status, but have not received a reply back.</p>

User Satisfaction

tooltip icon
We only include products on Welpr that are the best of the best. An EXCELLENT user satisfaction score indicates the product is in the top third of the best products.

Materials

tooltip icon

Pure Stainless Steel

Est. Price
$13.99
price-icon-1price-icon-2price-icon-3

Product Details

arrow down
  • Made from high-quality stainless steel without chemical coatings, promoting healthy and safe baking.
  • Consistent heat distribution ensures even cooking and beautiful browning.
  • Seamless and round edge design for easy cleaning and food release; dishwasher safe.
  • Sturdy construction resists warping, making it ideal for daily baking.
  • Suitable for various baking needs, including breads, cakes, and meatloaf.

Pros & Cons

arrow down

Pros

  • Made from stainless steel, ensuring no toxic chemicals or coatings.
  • Easy to clean with excellent nonstick performance.
  • Consistently bakes various bread types to perfection.
  • Durable and rust-resistant, holding up well over time.
  • Ideal for health-conscious bakers looking for a reliable, chemical-free option.

Cons

  • Some users found the pans to be shallower than preferred.
  • A few noted possible oxidation with certain breads if left in the pan too long.

arrow down
Our Product Rating System

Our Product Rating System

First, Camille (co-creator of Welpr) hand picks cleaner product options from a variety of sources.

Next, we collect information about each product's safety, consumer satisfaction, and eco-ethical standing.

Finally, we run all this information through an algorithm that calculates the Welpr Rating.

Welpr Rating:

5.0/5

The Welpr Rating takes into account 3 things:

  1. Product Safety
  2. Consumer Satisfaction
  3. Ethics & Environment
Product safety

Part 1: Product safety

We evaluate safety information from 3rd party organizations (e.g. EWG, Made Safe, etc.). Instead of relying solely on any one of these companies for safety information, we assess all of them.

Consumer satisfaction

Part 2: Consumer satisfaction

We scour the web for consumer ratings and reviews to verify products are not only cleaner options, but also effective. Products can either be Above Average, Average, or Below average for their respective category (e.g. cleaning products).

Ethics & Environment

Part 3: Ethics & Environment

When you buy a product, you’re supporting that company with your dollars. We believe it’s important to support ethical companies, so we pool together certifications that verify a company's ethics and environmental impact.

Chemical Name

Why it’s harmful

No items found.
about icon

Authors

Camille May, Product Curator

Hey, I’m Camille—co-creator of Welpr and your go-to guide for all things clean living. After selling my last company in the health food space, I went non-toxic to heal an autoimmune condition. It did wonders for my health, but navigating which products to buy wasn’t easy. We built Welpr to make that journey feel a bit easier.  When I’m not working on Welpr, you’ll usually find me in the sauna, sipping a raw milk latte while doing a puzzle, or walking with my pit bull Romeo in my hometown of Austin, TX.

Olushola M. Awoyemi, Medical Reviewer

Olushola M. Awoyemi (aka Shola) is a board-certified toxicologist and a research scientist with a PhD in Environmental Toxicology. Shola's long-term ambition is to be recognized as a world-renowned expert in toxicology, risk assessment, and management, with experience spanning across institutions like the US EPA, US FDA, NIEHS, USDA, UNEP, WHO, and possibly within Fortune 100 companies in the Chemical, Healthcare, Pharmaceutical, Consumer goods, or IT sectors.

Get "The Welpr Blueprint" Mini-Course

Go non-toxic, fast. Without the overwhelm. We'll guide you through the swaps that'll make the biggest difference on your health.